Claudio Fernández-Aráoz, the longtime Egon Zehnder partner, once wrote in Harvard Business Review that talent is less portable than we assume. Drawing on Boris Groysberg's research, he noted that performance depends on processes, platforms, products, people, and politics, and most of those stay behind when a leader moves.
Of those, I think people is the one we underestimate most.
A successful leader usually knows their team well. They know where it's strong and where it needs development. They know who works well together, where trust is solid, and where energy drops. Much of their track record rests on that knowledge, built up over years and rarely written down.
When they move, none of it comes with them. They arrive with the same skills and a team they can't yet read. So they do what most new leaders do: they observe, they hold one-on-ones, they form impressions. Those impressions take months to sharpen, and early ones are often wrong.
Meanwhile, the sponsor who backed the hire is expecting the results the old knowledge made possible.
The gap isn't in the leader's ability. It's in what the leader knows about the team's climate: the motivation, trust, teamwork, and autonomy that decide how much of the leader's ability can actually be used. Some of that can only come with time. But a leader who starts with an honest picture of the team's strengths and development needs doesn't have to rebuild it entirely on their own.
For anyone backing a transition, the question is how long you're willing to let your new leader work without that picture, and what it costs while they do.
